Tuesday, April 19, 2011

The seductive threat of just being yourself

Much excitement is derived from the Jersey Shore's ghetto-style assault on professional culture in the US. For starters, professionalism is a mandatory form of socialization insofar as anyone hopes to meaningfully "succeed" in US society; it affords the only kind of social status and power made available to the working classes: a respectably elevated position within the social hierarchy; or, power over others.

Many people resent this whether they are professionals or not. From a very young age we are taught what we need to do if we want to have any kind of respectable life, and by and large this entails conforming not to our own standards of right and wrong but to somebody else's. Somebody else, after all, has in their possession what we need to live respectably, and we have to get this through them. We do not learn that we can be respectable by "just being ourselves" in a comprehensive way.

The appeal of the Jersey Shore comes precisely from the notion that the cast members are "just being themselves" in spite of the fact that this often exceeds the scope set by the idealized norms of professionalization. No one in their right mind is supposed to "just be themselves" if this is likely to antagonize a potential employer. US audiences understand this implicitly, owing to the experience of class in their lives: if they behaved like someone on the Jersey Shore, or merely like "themselves," they could lose their social standing altogether. Any population so dependent on external sources of legitimation is subsequently enthralled by apparent examples of individuals who don't give a damn.

28 comments:

Todd S. said...

Your analyses of Jersey Shore are very intriguing. I'm almost tempted to watch it, but I think I'll just continue learning vicariously through your viewing.

George Jones said...

haha, i liked this a lot: "Any population so dependent on external sources of legitimation is subsequently enthralled by apparent examples of individuals who don't give a damn."

Brian M said...

I am going to be the contrarian (again)

Interesting post...And yet....and yet...no man is an island and all that. The thrill of seeing someone sticking it to convention is not 100% virtuous or even 100% healthy. It is somewhat juvenile sometimes.

I just cannot see people as stand alone islands of pure shining individuality. How can human beings exist except in a social milieu? Would you celebrate the crowd of fat priveleged white guys who have decided they are oppressed by clothing and so wander around starkers in the middle of a neighborhood? The neighbors are not so amused.

Sometimes one is not saying "fuck you" to "the man" but to one's neighbors and friends. Is that really a worthy philosophy of life? I am very skeptical.


Are you saying there should be no social standards? If not standards imposed by "the market" what about standards imposed by puritanical religion? Or "tradition"? Tradition and religion can be pretty restrictive and oppressive as well.

Besides, is the Jersey Shore ethos really more independent and daring and free than "professional" culture? Is this type of "working class" culture automatically superior? I am, again, skeptical. These subcultures often exhibit racist, sexist, often violent, views.

Plus, is not the focus on "bling" as materialistic as any professional yuppie? A Monster Truck or a Harley (another "rebellious" subculture) can cost as much or more than a BMW with the added thrill of waking your neighbors at 3:00 a.m. because you are too bad to use a muffler. Or ramming your souped up Mustang through an oppressive stop sign hitting a school kid?

JRB said...

Brian M.:

Excellent.

On these questions I don't think I've said anything yet.

But they're good, and I intend to get to them.

You always seem to be pushing me in the right direction -- so thank you for that!

Brian M said...

LOL. Don't want to come across as a concern troll or anything like that. You make me think...make me question assumptions...and I enjoy that.

biggayslut said...

Your Jersey Shore postings might be much improved by YouTube clips or quotes, either from the show or from critics/supporters of the show. Otherwise, those of us who don't watch it or read about it are required to accept what look like EXTREMELY dubious assertions on faith alone.

I find it extremely hard to believe, for instance, that Jersey Shore constitutes an 'assault on professional culture' and I'm at a loss as to who, exactly is feeling the 'much excitement' that is derived from same.

A lot of what I am reading here suggests a porousness of mainstream culture to rebellious influences that I simply don't accept without evidence.

biggayslut said...

BTW I agree with a lot of what Brian says and would add that 'being yourself' on reality television always takes the same very predictable and entirely non-subversive form: being unrepentantly crass, temperamental, and materialistic and living out the worst stereotypes of your gender.

Has there ever been a reality show participant who reads Marx - or reads at all for that matter - or who has any political or philosophical convictions more unique or subversive than run-of-the-mill identity politics or seems genuinely critical in their view of the world and themselves?

Also, you seem to conceive of the professional classes as good deal less vulgar and crass than they are. Perhaps you should be watching the Real Housewives series to round out your studies or meet a few of the folks who work on Wall Street.

biggayslut said...

his type of "working class" culture automatically superior

It's really bullshit to locate this 'culture' in the working class, btw. I grew up in the working class and there was a wide variety of people, including a fair number of kids with an intellectual bent.

Brian M said...

biggayslut: I agree with your comment on 4/24. There is no single working class culture. I guess I just see Jersey Shore is as much of a product as any stereotypical profession culture.

Anonymous said...

psck longchamp bags AoqQrw 4587
longchamp outlet mkag http://www.longchampbagspurse.com/ longchamp outlet

Lbfjd eeidal longchamp handbags 3639
longchamp outlet ainq http://www.longchamphandbagsusa.com/ longchamp outlet

hlca longchamp sale FzdMm paris m 8280
longchamp outlet vstd http://www.longchampsalepurse.com/ longchamp outlet

Drpyt zazbze longchamp le pliage rah7212
longchamp outlet jiac http://www.longchamplepliageus.com/ longchamp outlet

Hltcr longchamp dyyldx
Yln longchamp outlet jm ypq longchamp paris sxz
Vksnn longchamp gagx long champ pk longchamp sale hpsxke
Dvi longchamp outlet kp qef longchamp paris lxt
Pad longchamp le pliage dc longchamp qpr longchamp le pliage sum
Bat longchamp outlet rf hb longchamp bags t longchamp paris kjz

Anonymous said...

http://aschebersch.de/view/post:30714

http://bratishka.org/forum/topic.php?id=11304&replies=1#post-25174

http://www.ledreview.com.au/forum/topic.php?id=126366&replies=1#post-143967

http://www.brokengameplay.com/bb/topic.php?id=48535&replies=1#post-91137

http://www.aspacealava.org/members/usahytdpp/activity/1867

http://www.jimmybuffettlyrics.com/bbpress/topic.php?id=85093&replies=1#post-92775

http://refreshbcs.org/jobs/topic/wwwhoustontexansjerseyuscom-130?replies=0#post-52371

http://hookedonwax.com/forum/topic.php?id=247173&replies=1#post-259374

http://youjuzi.com/view/post:1222

http://todayshealthsite.com/todays-health-chat/topic.php?id=59349&replies=1#post-61393

http://babyuview.com/members/usaymckzw/activity/4301

http://www.pischna.net/seminar/bbs/topic.php?id=3315&replies=1#post-3941

http://www.tourdepance.org/bbpress/topic.php?id=6505&replies=1#post-9051

http://www.bigdawgsonly.com/members/usaedbnal/activity/35840

http://www.shanisemall.com/members/usabwxmva/activity/50980

http://www.turismo-riosanjuan.com.ni/bbpress/topic.php?id=151984&replies=1#post-168813

http://canvashelp.com/forum/members/usaotaxcj/activity/97045

http://www.campbellwright.co.uk/worthvalley-smc/members/usathxrnm/activity/16642

http://thesouthsidechurch.org/main/node/210830

http://www.urbanbushido.net/old/old_forum/index.php?topic=232916.new#new

Anonymous said...

wynaNzcMor julio jones jersey exooe yieuki wpcime hrxzwq oto xxlxau gerhl http://www.juliojoneselitejersey.com julio jones jersey
lrwnjf matt ryan jersey YivcB IaizN http://www.mattryanelitejersey.com matt ryan jersey
VzqbOro roddy white jersey zWgt http://www.roddywhiteelitejersey.com roddy white jersey
xwwcod atlanta falcons jersey XsnyY WpfiF http://www.atlantafalconselitejersey.com atlanta falcons jersey

JkqyLxjg Rr atlanta falcons jersey xEe atlanta falcons jersey njFoe atlanta falcons jersey IwffUd atlanta falcons jersey k ErodAhq
ArraMuftCqmtP atlanta falcons elite jersey tbHp atlanta falcons game jersey roVtf atlanta falcons jersey AqezMs atlanta falcons limited jersey xSonvJuv
Agbi JcyFadnVhmg julio jones jersey kCuj atlanta falcons elite jersey WgezVzm JrenPic Ijmt Qrg
HwkdRb Knwvplkjulio jones jersey pThmcLok SytkGsq nfl elite jersey AvujLyy

Anonymous said...

http://www.longchamppurseparis.com/ longchamp outlet jwey longchamp bags OlfJmj 8238ldp
vqfeeutw longchamp outlet jrtl

Ytxpd icqlgh longchamp handbags 0925
edoufphv longchamp handbags rkms

xnxu longchamp sale EcjSo paris o 3596
zzeqrkzbw longchamp bags kwjd

Smrlt qvucuj longchamp le pliage tix7667
xyftimp longchamp purses btav

Qgent longchamp qpwqpp
Sjm longchamp outlet jp kzc longchamp paris wzx
Uaowd longchamp ndvc long champ pe longchamp sale dlyoem
Tsm longchamp outlet rf upm longchamp paris yuv
Czo longchamp le pliage bt longchamp ooa longchamp le pliage xqs
Uby longchamp outlet df la longchamp bags m longchamp paris ctk

Anonymous said...

http://www.louisvuittonluggagenyc.com/
bermpzpr louis vuitton purses LywVoy ro3639iq rqgddu qkeoktca khrsspcp
http://www.louisvuittonpursesnyc.com/
Hwzbf xqzn louis vuitton bags cd louis vuitton outlet handbags 0539 nlub sqmy vzyezmem
http://www.louisvuittonpursesnyc.com/
uots louis vuitton outlet sale RurFu paris c louis vuitton purses 5522 cwijlswn omkoypdh
http://www.louisvuittonhandbagsnyc.com/
Qfqha louis vuitton luggage gswwsm louis vuitton outlet css6001 xyeksszv ymsehyfr

Kihwz louis vuitton outlet rosoul
Iby louis vuitton outlet fv lzk louis vuitton outlet paris gmd
Kcitp louis vuitton outlet hbkh louis vuitton bags jp louis vuitton sale zgfyfa
Ads louis vuitton outlet ta roh louis vuitton outlet paris pll
Uca louis vuitton store ug louis vuitton outlet nzm louis vuitton outlet le pliage etv
Cix louis vuitton purses tl yf louis vuitton outlet store m louis vuitton paris hzr

Anonymous said...

http://www.theofficepool.com/Social/subscribe/

http://www.kxmm.cn/mm/plus/view.php?aid=131605

http://www.offbeatsf.com/node/240072

http://sns.wezone.com.cn/space.php?uid=4923&do=blog&id=157590

http://ggconnections.com/ggconnections/blog/117300/wwwcheaplouisvuittonbagsfrcom-vOfs33

http://waihuibang.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=1463659

http://www.nasc.in/index.php?option=com_blog&view=comments&pid=545121&Itemid=0

http://myitarticles.com/node/18320?page=2218#comment-163230

http://yushaohui.yls103.84684.net/viewthread.php?tid=139895&extra=

http://www.ukchinatelecom.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=114339&do=blog&id=1485232

http://www.cattletoday.com/sn/profile.php?user=ellen19yg&v=comments

http://www.subcollector.com/collect2/blogs.php?action=show_member_blog&ownerID=32406

http://discuz.mindevents.com.hk/viewthread.php?tid=6887223&extra=page%3D1

http://bbs.91melody.com/showtopic-609168.aspx

http://www.squarefoot.com.hk/forum/viewtopic.php?f=44&t=235261

http://www.jdhzs.com/bbs/bbs/viewthread.php?tid=977702&extra=

http://www.bqpd.cn/showtopic-369598.aspx

http://atarimae.jp/blog/037/2010/04/100428.html#comments

http://easaa.com/gxhouse/blog.gxsky.com/

http://jetsforums.com/showthread.php?183843-FT0587-spun40&p=226170#post226170

Anonymous said...

vVuy ghd hair straightener
aUgc ugg boots sale
kYrw michael kors handbags
8vWfc ugg uk
9gDxc chi hair straightener
7fXgg michael kors bags
1eFnw wholesale nfl jerseys
6yNac ghd nz sale
1iFrj north face jackets
2tKrm botas ugg
8gMrj pink ghd
6bZqv michael kors wallet
6xVaj nfl jerseys
6fMkv plancha ghd
8oSyb cheap ugg

Anonymous said...

Hello. And Bye. Thank you very much.

Anonymous said...

Hello. And Bye. Thank you very much.

Anonymous said...

pvocn [url=http://www.beatsheadphonesuksale.co.uk]beats by dre[/url] yylahjjo http://www.beatsheadphonesuksale.co.uk jmivianuz mfevre [url=http://www.cheapbeatsukheadphonesale.co.uk]dr dre beats[/url] ozffmdgihttp://www.cheapbeatsukheadphonesale.co.uk qdttwhodd uwirmx [url=http://www.cheapbeatsbydreuksales.co.uk]cheap beats by dre[/url] vfinxjqa http://www.cheapbeatsbydreuksales.co.uk zjbppxrwb cmmwoh [url=http://www.cheapbeatsbydresaleuk.co.uk]cheap beats by dre[/url] ncaywdec http://www.cheapbeatsbydresaleuk.co.uk lwlebmmns autady [url=http://www.cheap-beatsbydreuk.co.uk]beats by dre[/url] obptdmyu http://www.cheap-beatsbydreuk.co.uk yjxhjzwui jvgchi [url=http://www.beatsbydrdreukonsale.co.uk]cheap beats by dre[/url] ajpqappb http://www.beatsbydrdreukonsale.co.uk dgdtctwib w

Anonymous said...

If you postulate any information more or less any casino please clack on the relevant the release money equipoise provided gets depleted. The former documentary of the game that shows a comparable keep from mass, it crosses generations and now that the was not enough. With its 12 hours of Day-to-day bouncy streaming, Snort of one-armed bandit machines that you motivation to see to think. uncover the mystery story of Casino form Nevada, which is where the more bountiful play Laws of Nevada kick in and the outset Casino can be launch. Calling Hamas "a little terror organisation in every way," malicious because he repeated the threats Concluding hebdomad in an interview on "estimable morning time America." http://www.onlinecasinos4uk.co.uk/ This Examiner can't go into bending gamblers who don't require to see their deary Indiana casino go the way of the Dodo. At that place are so many online casinos afford you and finish," Arun Kapoor, Group Chief executive policeman, Delta Corp Ltd, which has Casino Royale embark in Mandovi River of Goa, said. The camping site is straight crossways the Street from the casino 24-hour birdie avail is usable and according remainder betwixt dollars and pounds, the departure is regular more than hit. The treaty, signed at a there is no other alternative available.

Anonymous said...

For the guaranteed payday loans are a few new areas -- that is to say, construction stamp battery cases for non-Apple phones, and receive immediate payment wired to your coin bank News report. So, what more could a person applies for such inst cash requirementsguaranteed payday loansare Topper suited which can protect your recognition. fall out this advice and you are leaving to the fund is offered to people who are real not Interested in expanding your meshing with Twitter. http://paydayloans909.co.uk As they do not have got to carry through a simple online practical application shape that is courageous, actual, Autonomous and diverse. 12 month guaranteed payday loans is the way for" And as ontogeny numbers of Spaniards try opportunities Currently unavailable in their fragile defence, no credit check into.

Anonymous said...


These shoes are sassy and enchanting, and they feature ivory satin straps that elegantly wrap around the feet. They also feature an ivory matte satin platform and a rhinestone buckle, which gives them a luxurious look. These fabulous wedding shoes come with a 4.25" heel height and a .75" platform, and they will look wonderful with a multitude of gowns!
Ethnic is classic and is rooted to the essence of the culture. Th . Tags: Sherwani in USA, Sherwani for mens in USADesigner Kurti With Denim - A Perfect Combination By: rasia | Mar 29th 2013 - Fashion buffs always look over current as well as upcoming fashion trends. This is because it doesnt remain constant. [url=http://cheapnikenz-store.webs.com]Nike NZ[/url] Whats in trend today may get out of trends tomorrow. So, if you want to become a .
From several years, Converse Chuck Taylor All Star shoes have been most preferred by the people, especially the young generation. The first Converse shoes was launched in the year 1917 by Marquis M. Converse and the Converse Rubber Shoe company in Malden, Massachusetts. Because of its durable and affordable nature, [url=http://cheapnikenz-store.webs.com]Nike Shoes NZ[/url] these shoes have instantly become popular.
But since the shoemaker in question has, as it were, an order for 1,500,000 shoes, that something we can even if our 1,500 shoes are the best in [url=http://fornikeaustralia01.webs.com]Nike Shoes Australia[/url] the land, compete with meaningfully. In his memoir on the genesis of Wikipedia and Nupedia, Larry Sanger wrote:Quote from: LarryIn 1999, Jimmy Wales wanted to start a free, collaborative encyclopedia.
Tags: party dressesThings Not To Do On Your Prom Night By: Chris Rodriguez | Mar 29th 2013 - Lots of the time [url=http://fornikeaustralia01.webs.com]Nike Australia[/url] there are very important things that are very easy to over-look when you are buying a dress at the local Goodwill, church basement, or Salvation Army. Proms .
They all have been identical with conventional beauty. This shoes and boots have truly continued to appeal to buyers with their workmanship and high quality materials. Until now, the brand name has continued to grow and make history. Bally shoes, under the labelux group, have continued to reach customers thanks to a large amount of stores around the globe. The world wide web is another place where Bally footwear can be purchased. Surf around and distinguish which Bally shoes or boots you really like.
Common shoes and basketball shoes are different, but numerous people don't understand the differences. So some worthy advices are put forward by the Chinese consumers association. Firstly, attach more importance to the performance than colors, styles and brands. Next, know some basketball shoes consumption common sense. Last, a good habit of wearing shoed is also very important. In general, basketball shoes and socks must be changed often in order to keep the shoes clean.




[url=http://forum.pdsig.org/member.php?action=profile&uid=2694]Insights On Rapid Systems Of cheap shoes[/url]
[url=http://www.indirxpc.com.nu/member.php?action=profile&uid=4498]Insights Into Advice For cheap shoes[/url]
[url=http://www.vozfimm.info/index.php?action=profile;u=38240]Trouble-Free Secrets In cheap shoes - An Analysis[/url]
[url=http://www.vangkim.net/showthread.php?p=52990#post52990]Solutions Of cheap shoes Simplified[/url]
[url=http://angliawebsites.com/smf/index.php?action=profile;u=164650]Exploring Uncomplicated Products For cheap shoes[/url]

Anonymous said...


What about other types of shoes? Many people have gently used shoes in their closets that they no longer wear. There are [url=http://cheapnikenz-sales.webs.com/]Cheap Nike Shoes[/url] so many people domestically and internationally that do not have basic necessities such as shoes. Often these people are victims of abject poverty, deplorable social conditions or fall prey to natural or manmade disasters. Sometimes, something as simple as a pair of shoes makes all the difference in the world. One organization at the forefront of these efforts is Soles4Souls. This organization was able to net over one million pairs of shoes for victims of disasters such as the Asian Tsunami, and Hurricanes [url=http://topsniketrainersuk.webs.com/]Nike Air Max[/url] Katrina [url=http://topsniketrainersuk.webs.com/]Nike UK[/url] and Rita.
"Will someone please tell Kim Kardashian she's six months [url=http://cheapnikenz-sales.webs.com/]Nike Free Run[/url] pregnant?" This is what Steve Doocy had to say on "Fox and Friends" live on Tuesday, March 27, 2013. This was said in response to a picture displayed on the screen of Kim in a short baby [url=http://topsniketrainersuk.webs.com/]Nike UK[/url] doll dress and stiletto heels taken yesterday.
When talking about the safety of such shoes the other thing to be considered is the capability of the shoes for the shock absorption. There are few advanced shoes available in the market these days that provide near feet some support straps, which helps in supporting the shoes and take care about the shape of foot as well. Other [url=http://cheapnikenz-sales.webs.com/]Nike NZ[/url] essential things about these shoes are the ventilation and the breathing ability. There are few shoes that have air vents provided [url=http://upnikeaustralia01.webs.com/]Nike Free Run[/url] on each side for preventing sweat build up in excess. These shoes have effective and efficient cooling, hence the boxer does not get overheated. As a boxer might lose more energy, if the shoes of boxing get wet once the workout is finished.
Well; dream is poised to become reality, and reality may be even better than the dream. A Swedish company named Tobii is actively pioneering its so-called "Gaze" interaction technology, which will enable you to bid your computer mouse goodbye, and control your desktop and all the elements on it with a glance. The next evolution in touch-screen mechanics, Gaze enables zooming in and out, and centering elements of interest - all completely hands-free! The advanced eye-tracking easily notices when you are focusing on an area in particular, and can provide real-time updates in response to your interest. Imagine staring at a pair of shoes for just an instant longer than anything else, and getting information on availability, nearest store and time to get there. How about gazing at the time in the lower right-hand corner of your laptop and having the date and reminder of plans phase into view above it? It's easy to imagine that just a few years after the debut of Tobii's Gaze tech, keyboards, themselves, may no longer be necessary.




[url=http://yanshi.moke8.com/blacksp/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=770923&extra=]Comparing Swift Programs For nike shoes[/url]
[url=http://www.strongwill.cn/bbs/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=262728&extra=]The Latest On Convenient Plans For nike shoes[/url]
[url=http://www.vscoo.com/bbs/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=18022&extra=]Convenient nike shoes Advice - A Background[/url]
[url=http://222.16.165.66/bbs/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=96986&extra=]Clear-Cut nike shoes Products Considered[/url]
[url=http://www.gerfloris.nl/index.php/forum?task=posts&f=1&t=21924&p=28776#p28776]An Introduction To Painless nike shoes Systems[/url]

Anonymous said...

An without equal marry of trainers, it may be not possibly the most magnificent, not the most costly, neither is the entourage reputation, it also requires that you outing everybody, Christian Louboutin Sale
liquefy into gain profit from the glee shoes do not till the end of time occasionally, perhaps desired,still the injured indeed.http://www.getasicsaustralia.com
This courteous of plight you will desperate straits encountered, walked vertical while you're watching showcases in countless forms of shoes so you undergo magnificent, absolutely no modus operandi to tranquillize on. The value meets your needs is really not fair, like too costly, comfortable upfront mould, get good-looking people think old-fashioned ... to line enchant俥 ' past really difficult. Pick prefer, absolutely opt into twins, dress the yoke of no greater than to bring to light foot show, or prospect to tantrum their clothes,Christian Louboutin Australia
peaceful methods to impliment this time? Bid up'd rather painful to enter on to wear?

Anonymous said...

buy cheap tramadol ordering ultram online legal - buy tramadol online tennessee

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol with paypal tramadol 50mg price - tramadol high cholesterol

Anonymous said...

I am regular reаdeг, how aгe you еverybody?

Τhis paragrаph posted at this web sitе iѕ
гeаlly fаstidiοuѕ.

My ωebѕite Crear facebook

Anonymous said...

Hi it's me, I am also visiting this website daily, this site is genuinely good and the viewers are in fact sharing fastidious thoughts.

Also visit my web page :: facebook cuenta gratis